[pct-l] Shelter Question

[csx at schizoaffective.org (csx@schizoaffective.org)]

Grandma Gatewood did just fine wrapped up in a shower curtain.
http://www.letterboxing.org/BoxView.asp?boxnum=11682&boxname=Grandma_Gatewood_and_her_Keds



On Thu, 3 Nov 2005 00:27:46 -0800 (PST), yogi <yogihikes@sbcglobal.net> had this
to say:

>Switchback asks, "why do we need any shelter in the first place?"
> 
>uh . . . well . . . there was a hiker in 2003 who posed the same question.  His "shelter" was a piece of tyvek.  When we had a hypothermic rain storm coming out of Warner Springs, some fellow hikers found him in his sleeping bag with the tyvek wrapped around him, trying to stay warm and dry, but neither warm nor dry was happening.  The hikers rescued him (and a few other unprepared souls).
> 
>His trail name was So Far.
> 
>That day his name was changed to "So Far He's Not Dead".
> 
>yep, you need a shelter.  Something.  ANYTHING.  
> 
>yogi
>www.pcthandbook.com
> 
> 
>
>
>Hiker97@aol.com wrote:
>I know you people are REALLY going to be mad at me for posting another item 
>so soon. But I have been sitting here in my easy chair thinking for an hour 
>about this and cannot come up with an answer.
>
>As you know I am getting the Gossamer Gear SpinnTwin tarp at 9 ounces. See 
>_gossamergear.com/cgi-bin/gossamergear/Spinn-Twinn.html?_ 
>(http://www.gossamergear.com/cgi-bin/gossamergear/Spinn-Twinn.html?) But here is the shocker. 
>I do not plan on using it. I plan on just using it as an another layer of 
>ground cloth. I will have a ground cloth and then the tarp folded over so now 
>I have 3 layers under me and then my foam pad. The ground is the big robber 
>of warm, so this gives me some good protection.
>
>The only time I would put up the tarp is for rain or protection from the 
>sun. May be you would want it up for privacy in certain situations. That is 
>about it. Really hardly ever needed. I figure if I need a shelter for only 
>backup, it is going to be super super super light to carry every mile down the 
>trail. I have the Gossamer Gear Bug Canopy that I will modify into a bug 
>tent for 97% of my camping and 360 views/star gazing. Even mountainmen of old 
>hated bugs.
>
>The discussion on this list about different types of tents got me thinking 
>of why do we need any shelter in the first place. Back in the old days John 
>Muir, Norman Clyde, Henry Thoreau, King, Coby, Thompson, Carson, etc., etc., 
>did not normally use tents. If they set up a shelter system, they used 
>canvas/oil lean-to open shelters with a roaring fire on the open side if it was 
>cold. That was about it. If they came back today and saw the big deal and all 
>the discussions about tents and tarps they would laugh. I can just imagine 
>what they would call us big bad backpackers in the modern age - may be not to 
>our face, but certainly behind our backs. It would not be nice or a 
>complement. We would be highly embarrassed.
>
>It is the same with my previous discussions on getting the Nunatak sleeping 
>bag and down sweater. I could not look the mountainmen of old in the face 
>and explain what it was all about. I would be too ashamed. Too embarrassed. 
>What a joke. I must be out in left field on this one. Everyone is so 
>wrapped up in modern gear, including me, that it is a little ridiculous.
>
>I will shut up now. Thank you for your attention.
>
>Your hiking buddy, Switchback
>Gear Hacker & Mountainman Want-A-Be
>_______________________________________________
>pct-l mailing list
>pct-l@mailman.backcountry.net
>unsubscribe or change options:
>http://mailman.hack.net/mailman/listinfo/pct-l
>_______________________________________________
>pct-l mailing list
>pct-l@mailman.backcountry.net
>unsubscribe or change options:
>http://mailman.hack.net/mailman/listinfo/pct-l